Home Forums Salem Place: The Main Board Melanie & Carly

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #287
    Misty004
    Participant

    Sorry I must have missed an episode…but when did Carly realize, find out that it was Melanie that was her daughter and not Mia?

    #9979
    kprstrs
    Participant

    I thought she always knew which one it was, but the viewers were ‘toyed’ with for a while.

    #9980
    Patti
    Participant

    she knew when her own daughter was born, and there’s at least 2 or 3 years difference between Mel and Mia, but that still doesn’t answer how she knew for sure it was Melanie.  There must be any number of girls that age living in Salem, so how did she know for sure.  And how did she know that her daughter was living with Maggie?  Too many loose ends for me.

    #9985
    kprstrs
    Participant

    There are definitely a lot of loose ends, but that never stopped them (writers) before. I just thought that the ??’s were supposed to be for the audience’s benefit, I could most assuredly be wrong!

    #9986
    IzzyB
    Participant

    She mentioned that Lawrence made her give the baby to "that man" and she knew that he was evil.  So if she knew who he was (Trent) then it would be pretty easy to track down who she was.  She did mention something about tracking her down, so I imagine that is what she did.  Find out what happened with Trent, find her daughter.

    #9988
    53tdogs
    Participant

    Kinsey????  Hahahhahhaha!   Total retribution!

    #9989
    kprstrs
    Participant

    Oh my!!  That would be hilarious!!!

    #9990
    Bonbon
    Participant

    BTW, I forgot, who killed Trent?

    #9992
    DeeLan
    Participant

    Nick killed Trent and he’s in prison now. 

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.