Home Forums Salem Place: The Main Board What’s Melanie’s problem?

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • Author
  • #78

    What was up with the reaction Melanie had to Carly?  I mean okay she spilled coffee on her accidentally, so what?  Melanie’s reaction was waaaaay over the top.  She’s so upset about Nathan dumping her that she has to be rude to Carly and Mia and Gabby?  I know she’s young (too young for Phillip) but please!  She really has been a witch with a B lately.


     how she wanted her first time meeting her daughter to be "special" or something like that so I’m guessing that Mel will turn out to be her daughter because it was anything but special!  lol


    need to come up with some new ideas.  Do they think they are fooling us with Melanie’s attitude toward Carly?  It is so obvious that Mel is Carly’s daughter, I’m betting with Daniel, and in a few weeks, if I’m wrong, I’ll be the first to say so; however, lately I’ve lost count on how many predictable outcomes to sls we’ve been able to figure out way before they’ve been shown.  I and others suggested Daniel might have been the doctor Carly had an affair with weeks ago; same thing with Melanie being the daughter instead of Mia, even though we do tend to forget that although Melanie appears older, she is still only 18 or 19.  It’s not surprising; it’s simply poor writing, to me, when the fans can figure out where the writers are going before they even take us there. (LOL) 


    Although I like Melanie better than when she first appeared, this girl still gets on my nerves to some extent. It’s getting old with me the way she stammers to get a thought out, and I agree her reaction at the cafe was absurd and a sure bet she’s Carly’s kid.
    And you can further bet Doc Dan is the dad since Chloe can’t (at the moment anyway!) have kids.

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.